Penalty Box Menu
244 items in 19 sections · $0.50 – $70.00 · Bar & Grill in Scranton, PA
Penalty Box’s menu lists 244 dishes and drinks, grouped into FOOD - Appetizers, FOOD - Salads, FOOD - Specialty Sandwiches, FOOD - Penalty Box Pizza, FOOD - Wings, and FOOD - Quesadillas and more. Prices range from $0.50 to $70.00, and a typical item costs about $9.79. Popular choices include 12 Steamed Clams, Brisket Salad, Beef Steak Hoagie, Chicken Wing Full Tray, and 10 Wings.
FOOD - Appetizers 30
- 12 Steamed Clams$11.99
- Appetizers Platter$11.59
- Bag Of Chips$0.50
- Breaded Mushrooms$6.29
- Broccoli Ched Bites$7.39
- Cajun Chips$1.95
- Calamari Fries$8.29
- Cauliflower Wings$8.29
- Chicken Fries$6.29
- Chicken Tenders$7.29
- Chorizo & Cheddar Stuffed Jalapeno$9.79
- Cold Pickles$1.95
- Deep Fried Italian Wontons$9.19
- Deep Fried Pickles$6.29
- French Fries$3.29
- Irish Nachos$7.79
- Mini Tacos$6.49
- Mozzarella Sticks$6.89
- Nacho Grande$10.99
- Onion Rings$5.49
- Pierogies$6.29
- Polish Wings$6.79
- Potato Pancakes$5.59
- Potato Skins$8.49
- Spicy Corn Nuggets$7.49
- Spicy Green Bean Fries$6.59
- Steak Fries$3.29
- Tater Tots$3.29
- Vegetable Pot Stickers$7.29
- Waffle Fries$3.29
FOOD - Salads 9
- Brisket Salad$12.29
- Caesar Salad$6.89
- Chef Salad$12.29
- Chicken Wing Salad$12.29
- Large Tossed$6.89
- Penalty Box Cobb$12.29
- Small Caesar Salad$4.29
- Small Tossed$4.29
- Taco Salad$11.29
FOOD - Specialty Sandwiches 33
- Beef Steak Hoagie$9.99
- Beef Steak Wrap$9.99
- Blackened Tuna$11.99
- BLT$6.29
- Brisket Melt$12.29
- Chicken Caesar Wrap$8.99
- Chicken Cheese Hoagie$9.99
- Chicken Cheese Wrap$9.99
- Chicken Parmesan Hoagie$9.99
- Chicken Ranch Wrap$9.99
- Chicken Tender Bacon Melt$10.79
- Chorizo Wrap$9.99
- Cuban$11.99
- Double Double B.L.T.$8.49
- Filet Mignon Sandwich$12.99
- Grilled Cheese$5.29
- Gyro$9.99
- Habanero Chicken Sand$11.99
- Heaven & Hell Grilled Cheese$9.49
- Honey Ham Ciabatta$10.49
- Hot Wing Hoagie$9.99
- Hot Wing Wrap$9.99
- Italian Ciabatta$10.49
- Italian Melt$10.49
- Penalty Box Grilled Cheese$9.49
- Pork Bbq Sandwich$10.59
- Reuben$10.49
- Roast Beef Cheddar Ciabatta$10.49
- Roast Beef Cheddar Melt$10.79
- Southwest Tacos$5.99
- Sweet Sausage$8.99
- Turkey Ciabatta$10.49
- Turkey Reuben$10.49
FOOD - Penalty Box Pizza 16
- Chicken Wing Full Tray$15.79
- Chicken Wing Half Tray$8.99
- Flat Bread Pizza- Red$7.99
- Flat Bread Pizza-Tomato Garlic$7.99
- Flatbread Chicken Wing$9.49
- Personal Chicken Wing Pizza$8.69
- Personal Red Pizza$7.99
- Personal Tomato Garlic Pizza$8.69
- Personal White Pizza$7.99
- Red Full Tray$13.49
- Red Half Tray$7.99
- Red Flatbread Special (Wednesday)$5.99
- Tomato Garlic Full Tray$15.79
- Tomato Garlic Half Tray$8.99
- White Full Tray$14.49
- White Half Tray$8.99
FOOD - Wings 10
- 10 Wings$15.00
- 15 Wings$22.00
- 20 Wings$30.00
- 25 Wings$37.50
- 30 Wings$45.00
- 50 Piece Order (ONE SAUCE ONLY)$70.00
- Boneless Wings$8.49
- Bucket Of Boneless$33.29
- Buffalo Shrimp$8.79
- Cup Of Wing Sauce$3.50
FOOD - Quesadillas 7
- Beef Quesadilla$9.89
- Buffalo Chix Quesadilla$9.89
- Buffalo Shrimp Quesadilla$9.79
- Chicken Quesadilla$9.89
- Southwestern Chicken Quesadilla$9.79
- Southwestern Chorizo Sausage Quesadilla$9.79
- Three Cheese Quesadilla$9.29
FOOD - Pick Your Burger 4
- The Quarter Pounder$6.99
- The Half Pounder$9.99
- The One Pound Penalty Burger$14.99
- 1\4 Lb Burger With Fries (Monday Only)$6.99
FOOD - Speciality Burgers 8
- A1 Peppercorn Bacon Burger$12.99
- Angus Steak Burger$14.59
- Bbq Bacon Bleu Burger$13.99
- Carolina Burger$12.99
- Hells Burger (Medium \Well Only)$14.99
- Jalapeno Ranch Burger$12.99
- Patty Melt$12.99
- Southwest Bacon Burger$11.99
FOOD - extras 1
- Extra
Appetizers 30
- 12 Steamed Clams$11.99
- Appetizers Platter$11.59
- Bag Of Chips$0.50
- Breaded Mushrooms$6.29
- Broccoli Ched Bites$7.39
- Cajun Chips$1.95
- Calamari Fries$8.29
- Cauliflower Wings$8.29
- Chicken Fries$6.29
- Chicken Tenders$7.29
- Chorizo & Cheddar Stuffed Jalapeno$9.79
- Cold Pickles$1.95
- Deep Fried Italian Wontons$9.19
- Deep Fried Pickles$6.29
- French Fries$3.29
- Irish Nachos$7.79
- Mini Tacos$6.49
- Mozzarella Sticks$6.89
- Nacho Grande$10.99
- Onion Rings$5.49
- Pierogies$6.29
- Polish Wings$6.79
- Potato Pancakes$5.59
- Potato Skins$8.49
- Spicy Corn Nuggets$7.49
- Spicy Green Bean Fries$6.59
- Steak Fries$3.29
- Tater Tots$3.29
- Vegetable Pot Stickers$7.29
- Waffle Fries$3.29
Salads 9
- Brisket Salad$12.29
- Caesar Salad$6.89
- Chef Salad$12.29
- Chicken Wing Salad$12.29
- Large Tossed$6.89
- Penalty Box Cobb$12.29
- Small Caesar Salad$4.29
- Small Tossed$4.29
- Taco Salad$11.29
Specialty Sandwiches 33
- Beef Steak Hoagie$9.99
- Beef Steak Wrap$9.99
- Blackened Tuna$11.99
- BLT$6.29
- Brisket Melt$12.29
- Chicken Caesar Wrap$8.99
- Chicken Cheese Hoagie$9.99
- Chicken Cheese Wrap$9.99
- Chicken Parmesan Hoagie$9.99
- Chicken Ranch Wrap$9.99
- Chicken Tender Bacon Melt$10.79
- Chorizo Wrap$9.99
- Cuban$11.99
- Double Double B.L.T.$8.49
- Filet Mignon Sandwich$12.99
- Grilled Cheese$5.29
- Gyro$9.99
- Habanero Chicken Sand$11.99
- Heaven & Hell Grilled Cheese$9.49
- Honey Ham Ciabatta$10.49
- Hot Wing Hoagie$9.99
- Hot Wing Wrap$9.99
- Italian Ciabatta$10.49
- Italian Melt$10.49
- Penalty Box Grilled Cheese$9.49
- Pork Bbq Sandwich$10.59
- Reuben$10.49
- Roast Beef Cheddar Ciabatta$10.49
- Roast Beef Cheddar Melt$10.79
- Southwest Tacos$5.99
- Sweet Sausage$8.99
- Turkey Ciabatta$10.49
- Turkey Reuben$10.49
Penalty Box Pizza 16
- Chicken Wing Full Tray$15.79
- Chicken Wing Half Tray$8.99
- Flat Bread Pizza- Red$7.99
- Flat Bread Pizza-Tomato Garlic$7.99
- Flatbread Chicken Wing$9.49
- Personal Chicken Wing Pizza$8.69
- Personal Red Pizza$7.99
- Personal Tomato Garlic Pizza$8.69
- Personal White Pizza$7.99
- Red Full Tray$13.49
- Red Half Tray$7.99
- Red Flatbread Special (Wednesday)$5.99
- Tomato Garlic Full Tray$15.79
- Tomato Garlic Half Tray$8.99
- White Full Tray$14.49
- White Half Tray$8.99
Wings 10
- 10 Wings$15.00
- 15 Wings$22.00
- 20 Wings$30.00
- 25 Wings$37.50
- 30 Wings$45.00
- 50 Piece Order (ONE SAUCE ONLY)$70.00
- Boneless Wings$8.49
- Bucket Of Boneless$33.29
- Buffalo Shrimp$8.79
- Cup Of Wing Sauce$3.50
Quesadillas 7
- Beef Quesadilla$9.89
- Buffalo Chix Quesadilla$9.89
- Buffalo Shrimp Quesadilla$9.79
- Chicken Quesadilla$9.89
- Southwestern Chicken Quesadilla$9.79
- Southwestern Chorizo Sausage Quesadilla$9.79
- Three Cheese Quesadilla$9.29
Pick Your Burger 4
- The Quarter Pounder$6.99
- The Half Pounder$9.99
- The One Pound Penalty Burger$14.99
- 1\4 Lb Burger With Fries (Monday Only)$6.99
Speciality Burgers 8
- A1 Peppercorn Bacon Burger$12.99
- Angus Steak Burger$14.59
- Bbq Bacon Bleu Burger$13.99
- Carolina Burger$12.99
- Hells Burger (Medium \Well Only)$14.99
- Jalapeno Ranch Burger$12.99
- Patty Melt$12.99
- Southwest Bacon Burger$11.99
extras 5
- Extra
- Mild$0.50
- Ranch Side$0.50
- Blue Cheese Side$0.50
- Hot Side$0.50
EXTRAS - EXTRAS 4
- Mild$0.50
- Ranch Side$0.50
- Blue Cheese Side$0.50
- Hot Side$0.50
How these prices compare
Based on 37 menus with 1,586 priced items from bars & grills in Pennsylvania, the median menu item costs $10.00, and half of all items are priced between $6.99 and $13.97.
At Penalty Box the median listed price is $9.79, close to the typical $10.00 for bars & grills in Pennsylvania.
| Item | Here | Typical |
|---|---|---|
| Mozzarella Sticks | $6.89 | $8.22 |
| Onion Rings | $5.49 | $5.99 |
| Chef Salad | $12.29 | $12.49 |
| Blt | $6.29 | $7.99 |
| Grilled Cheese | $5.29 | $6.00 |
| Reuben | $10.49 | $12.99 |
| Wings | $15.00 | $15.00 |
Typical prices are calculated from 37 menus in our guide.
Menu items and prices are provided for information and may have changed (last updated April 2026). Allergen information is not included – please ask the restaurant.